Calumet Farm Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey Small Batch & Tatuaje Cojonu 2012 Cigar - Review

Calumet Farm Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey — Small Batch

Mash Bill: 91% Rye, 9% Malted Barley

ABV: 50% (100 Proof)

SRP: ~$90

The Pairing

The Tatuaje Cojonu 2012

Preface:

Calumet Farm’s 100 Year Anniversary Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey is a bold, high-rye expression that delivers both classic spice and refined balance. Bottled at a sturdy 100 proof, this small batch rye offers a warming, layered experience that’s as elegant as the brand’s thoroughbred legacy.

Nose:

The nose opens with a blanket of warm vanilla and soft caramel, quickly joined by a sprig of fresh mint and a whisper of white pepper. It’s inviting, with a pleasant interplay between sweetness and spice that hints at what’s to come.

Palate:

On the palate, this rye brings a creamy mouthfeel that delivers a surprising mint chocolate chip note—reminiscent of a dessert, but never overly sweet. A peppery backbone and classic baking spices (think cinnamon and clove) add complexity and rye-forward character, striking a balance between indulgence and assertiveness.

Finish:

The finish is long, warm, and viscous — the kind of Kentucky “hug” rye lovers crave. The spice slowly fades, leaving a lingering impression of dark mint and oak that invites another sip.

The Pairing:

Enter the Tatuaje Cojonu 2012 (SRP ~$12) — a Nicaraguan powerhouse with a full-bodied profile, known for its peppery spice, earthiness, and bold cocoa/espresso tones. It meets the Calumet rye with complementary intensity.

Together, the mint and spice of the rye cut through the cigar’s richness beautifully, refreshing the palate between draws. Meanwhile, the cigar’s deep tobacco and espresso flavors echo the whiskey’s sweet-spice balance, amplifying both without overwhelming either.

This is a pairing for experienced palates — where strength meets finesse, and boldness meets balance. A nightcap-worthy duo for anyone who enjoys the thrill of spice, depth, and complexity in both glass and smoke.